The South Ossetia crisis continues. Yesterday, the Russian government announced yesterday that it would recognize the two (former?) Georgian regions, Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Nato’s Secretary General, Jaap de Hoop Scheffer, condemned Russia’s move, saying it was a “direct violation of numerous UN Security Council resolutions regarding Georgia’s territorial integrity” and cautioning Russia that “Nato firmly supports the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Georgia and calls on Russia to respect these principles.”
South Ossetia and Abkhazia have long demanded independence from Georgia. But Russia’ recognition of the two has some important implications. The 1933 Montevideo Convention on Rights and Duties of States outlines the four fundamental criteria for statehood. According to the treaty,
The state as a person of international law should possess the following qualifications:
(a) a permanent population;
(b) a defined territory;
(c) government; and
(d) capacity to enter into relations with the other states.
The requirement that a state have the “capacity to enter into relations with other states” has usually been interpreted as meaning a state is recognized by other states. Unilateral recognition is not usually sufficient. Thus, Russia’s recognition of the two regions as independent states does not necessarily make them states. And the hesitation of other countries to follow suit suggests that further movement towards statehood may not be forthcoming. Recognition by the United Nations has usually been used as shorthand for meeting this criterion. But some states may choose not to participate as members of the United Nations (e.g., Switzerland), while others may be excluded for political reasons (e.g., Taiwan).
Deciding whether a state is a state or not can be surprisingly difficult. Some states fail to meet all of the criteria, particularly if we also carry over Weber’s definition that a state “possess a monopoly on the legitimate use of physical force.” By that definition, countries like Iraq Afghanistan, and Somalia would also not qualify, despite their membership in the United Nations.
Given this difficulty, it is also difficult to get an exact count on the number of states in the world. There are currently 192 members of the United Nations. The United States, however, recognizes 194 (including the Vatican and Kosovo, which are not recognized by the United Nations). Taiwan may also be added to the list. Palestine aspires to statehood, and the Palestinian government is recognized by many countries, but is not included in the total.